Blogs
Something in the air
29.07.10
Anthony Horowitz speculated recently that only old geezers such as him think that high street bookshops have a future. I beg to differ. My son, a digital marketer, umbilically attached to Apple, is sure that bookshops will survive. Oldies, in awe of digitisation, fear Armageddon.
How will shops survive? Through range, recommendation, cafés, events and wonderful staff, but also through something less definable, something which festivals are now being judged on. Atmosphere has made Glastonbury supreme, from early on, when John Peel marvelled: "Nine posts with coloured cloths fluttering from them—why? This mysterious pointlessness makes Glastonbury succeed." Latitude, a rising festival star, is totemically characterful.
As proof that bookshops have this atmos, think how you buy non-essential books from shops which turn you on. I have done this at Harvard Bookstore, Boston, Village Voice, Paris and Waterstone's Oban, to get a souvenir, a chunk of those shops' indefinable something.
Atmosphere is invisible but here are five things which contribute to it:
1) History. Cambridge has Britain's oldest bookshop, Byron shopped at Hatchards, Bath is where Tim Waterstone's son drove his Harley through the shop, Bournemouth branch is where a bookseller lost it and, crouching behind the till, served customers all day via two glove puppets, Rizzoli's New York is in "The Maltese Falcon". Shops do nothing with their history, but customers love it. We should all have a history-board for customers, because we sell narratives.
2) Ghosts and poltergeists. Discarnate entities love bookshops. Ask any bookseller and, sheepishly, out come the stories. Waterstone's security people deny all knowledge of the tape which shows locked doors open and close silently, not setting off the alarm, but they have it. Ironically it was a now-senior auditor who saw, in another branch, entire shelves full of books placed neatly on the floor. My own shop is awash with psycho-kinetic activity. Unverifiable tales, but customers love 'em.
3) Aroma. A nubile flame-haired customer lowered her voice as if confessing to a perversion: "I come in for the smell, I love it," a confession I have often heard.
4) Chat."The Public Sphere". Habermas' concept refers to his belief that the Enlightenment is not over. It is now carried on in unofficial, informal spaces like cafés and bookshops, successors of the Salons.
5) As humans with a heritage of animal reaction, we conduct intuitive psychic audits on our spaces. There exists an imper-sonal but spiritual resonance in places, pre-religious, something the Polynesians called mana, the Romans numen or, "the stuff magic is made from". Bookshops, old and new, indie or chain, all have it. Customers notice it quicker than sofas, coffee, bric-a-brac.
(iPads lack these five things.)
Comments on this article
By Blah blah blah
Every column this man writes shows how out of touch he is. Hilarious stuff, in a worrying way.29 Jul 10 16:09
By Inkozi
Look, I love bookshops. Browsing, buying, generally mooching around (when I can resisit the temptation to tidy the table displays), but this really is the most unutterable guff. Poltergeists? Psychic audits? Has the author been on the waccy baccy?30 Jul 10 08:28
By Daphne Bentwater
What bookshop customers want is knowledgeable, friendly, attentive staff and a decent stock of books that intelligent people might want to read together with a efficient and quick special ordering system. I don't need "history, ghosts and poltergeists, aroma (dear God...), or chat" nor do I need to "conduct intuitive psychic audits on my space" whe I go into any shop. Hells bells Blah x 3 I agree with you.30 Jul 10 10:24
By Darran
The three commentators above are wrong. If book shops are going to survive cultivating a sense of atmosphere and history are very important. That is why Foyles and Daunt are doing well. That is why Foyles produce postcards and other merchandise to highlight their history. That is why people proudly walk around with canvas bags with Foyles or Strand logos on them. That's also why it would be tragic if the ex-Borders on Glasgow Buchanan Street weren't taken over by a book store. That store would regularly have the highest turnover in the Borders chain world wide during the Christmas period, and Scots read more per capita than the English or Welsh. Come on Foyles, get in there.30 Jul 10 12:05
By Red Wheelbarrow Bookstore, Paris
I agree with your five things that contribute to 'atmosphere', it is not only 'atmosphere, atomosphere', but it is also that every living being needs at some point to feel they are alive, and special and actually exist, computers can not give this feedback- not really, people like to buy books in museum bookshops, - to make something of the experience of seeing art there own, part of them. This is what might be later on called something like' the movement of the real'.01 Aug 10 08:07
By Inkozi
@Darran - No, we are not "wrong". We are expressing an opinion, and in this case it's a perfectly valid one. There is a huge difference between a shop having a 'good feel' or 'pleasant atmosphere' and customers going there in the hope of bumping into the friendly in-store poltergeist. Likewise, stores that have a history, and play on that sense of history - such as Foyles, Hatchards etc - are to be admired, and hopefully, patronized. This, again, is in marked contrast to the nonsense above. I would go to Foyles/Hatchards etc in the hope of perhaps finding something different, or more pertinently, because they do make for excellent shops to browse in. They do not have a "spiritual resonance" - they just happen to be very fine bookshops.04 Aug 10 08:03
By Ex-Waterstone's Manager
Sorry Darren it's too late,the ex-Borders in Buchanan Street in Glasgow-a fantastic shop with great staff -is now a clothes shop.Virtually the only bookshops left in Glasgow now are Waterstone's branches and sadly they just aren't good bookshops nowadays.05 Aug 10 01:37
By PLR Articles Ebooks
PLR Articles EbooksThis is a wonderful opinion. The things mentioned are Great and needs to be appreciated by everyone.05 Aug 10 17:54
By Michael
@blah blah blah and Inkozi. The Sun is hilarious stuff too, if you take it literally. I'm pretty sure Martin is alluding to the indefinable allure of bookshops, something that is insubstantial and atmospheric. Digital publishing is definitely a growing trend, with Murdoch planning a tablet-only paper but some savvy publishers have increased traditional sales through digital promotion. The two go hand in hand, supporting each other.16 Aug 10 20:24
By martin latham
Shops, like houses, have an indefinable atmosphere.Over the last 23 years of bookselling,during which I have worked in independents and a chain, mostly on the shopfloor, customers have talked to me over and over about this. It's time we listened to them and stopped this modular approach to retail. Those who hand-wring over any mention of paranormal phenomena are of course, as Freud would allege, in a state of advanced subconscious repression.18 Aug 10 00:08
By David
"I come in for the smell, I love it," a confession I have often heard. And also a certain guarantee that they won't spend any money!04 Sep 10 11:19
See Also
Recent Blogs
- Stand together
- TWiC #35: Week Ending 28th August 2010
- For fonts' sake
- TWiC #34: Week ending 21st August 2010
- Worth fighting for?
Most Active
- 'Hooked on books' or 'Bookalicious'?
- To BA or not BA?
- Dressed to sell
- In praise of celebs
- Should you write on?
Latest Comments
- You know, no matter what anyone says, I belong to the school that believes that sans serif is...
- "I come in for the smell, I love it," a confession I have often heard. And also a certain...
- I heard many times about Damian Horner as a good marketing consultant and read many things...
- Ebooks just need to strike the right balance between the text and digital content. I think it's...
- Walter, I fear you've missed Katie's point. She was not suggesting that there are not enough...
RSS
Subscriber Content